How Our MatchCare Method Works

Our Six-Step Caregiver Matching Process

Our MatchCare Method is a six-step caregiver matching process that we use at Home Care Collective to bring the right caregiver into your mom’s home in Naples, Fort Myers, and across Southwest Florida: an initial consultation, an in-home assessment, caregiver matchmaking, a personalized care plan, ongoing support, and a planned transition when needs change.

So who picks your mom’s caregiver? Three team members make the decision: a registered nurse, our administrator who hires our caregivers, and our scheduler, who used to be a caregiver herself. Our software contributes to our short list, and our team makes the final choice. The choice is based on what we know about your mom and what we know about each caregiver. Then we follow up, and if the match isn’t right, we rematch under our Right Fit Guarantee.

What is the MatchCare Method?

It’s how we bring every new client into our care, from your first phone call to the day care changes.

There are six steps:

  1. Initial Consultation
  2. In-Home Assessment and Admission
  3. Caregiver Matchmaking
  4. Personalized Care Plan and Launch
  5. Ongoing Support and Evaluation
  6. Transition and Offboarding

Matching sits in the middle of the name for a reason. Your mom’s caregiver is the person she’ll see more than anyone else from our team. The first two steps are how we get to know her well enough to choose the right caregiver. The last three steps make sure that we choose the best option and adjust as needed when her needs change.

If there’s one idea behind all six steps, it’s to know the person. That’s the very first of the 56 Dementia Care Practice Recommendations the Alzheimer’s Association published in 2018, written by 27 dementia care experts. It’s how we approach in-home dementia care in Southwest Florida, and it’s how we approach every client, with or without a dementia diagnosis.

Why did we build the MatchCare Method this way?

Senior mother and her daughter smiling on her couch in her home

I saw what happens when the schedule picks the caregiver instead of the client’s needs.

Before starting Home Care Collective, I was an administrator at a Florida home care company and later became a director of nursing at another. I saw the same thing in both places. Whoever was available got the shift.

The schedulers just wanted to put the easiest person on the job. A four-hour case, three days a week, could end up with three different people. Why not have the same person?

Think about what that’s like for someone with memory loss or hearing loss. Every new face is a stranger. Every visit starts over. What about the client? What about their needs? Eventually, I left for the same reasons and started Home Care Collective.

This is why we believe caregiver consistency is so important in an industry that focuses more on the need.

The research backs this up. A 2023 review in The Gerontologist calls person-centered care the gold standard for people living with dementia. To be fair, the same review, which looked at care facilities, found mixed results for specific programs, and researchers are still learning what works best. We take that seriously. The MatchCare Method is how we practice person-centered care in a home, one client and one caregiver at a time.

Step 1: What happens at the initial consultation?

It starts with a short phone call, then a registered nurse meets you and your mom in person.

Most families find us through a referral or a search online. That first call is short on purpose. We cover a few basics and set up a time to meet, because I believe the best way to have these conversations is face to face.

The nurse comes to your mom’s home whenever it works for your family. Morning, afternoon, evening, or weekend are all fine. Live out of state? Join by phone or video call. Stay as long as you want, or keep it short. We can talk as long as you need to help you understand what help your mom needs and what her days look like. We’ll also tell you about us and why we started. A lot of the time, Step 2 happens during this same visit.

Is your mom pushing back on getting help? Tell us. We hear this often. Many older adults worry that accepting help means losing their independence, and they may not want to hear it from their kids. They often hear it differently from a professional. Make the introduction, and let us help you from there.

Step 2: What happens during the in-home assessment and admission?

A registered nurse assesses your mom, writes her care plan with you, and walks you through the paperwork.

The assessment covers your mom’s health, her routines, her home, and the help she needs right now. From there, the nurse writes her care plan with you at the table. That plan matters. Every caregiver must follow it, and no caregiver can make up their own approach. If you want to know more about the nurse’s role, our article on what RN oversight means for dementia care at home goes into detail.

Then comes the paperwork. I’ll be honest: it’s a lot like buying a new house, unfortunately. Florida’s licensing rules require most of it. Here’s what you’ll sign:

  • A service agreement
  • A rate sheet
  • A HIPAA privacy form
  • A client bill of rights, so your mom knows her rights as a client
  • A transportation policy, in case a caregiver drives your mom anywhere
  • A photo and authorized-signature form
  • A receipt for our client handbook

The handbook tells you how to report abuse or file a complaint, including a complaint about us. Once everything is signed, we’ll email copies to you and anyone else in the family who wants them.

Why do we put this much work in before choosing a caregiver? Because you can’t match someone you don’t know. The Alzheimer’s Association calls for regular, comprehensive person-centered assessments and timely interim assessments for exactly this reason, and everything we learn here goes straight into Step 3.

Step 3: How does caregiver matchmaking work?

Our caregiver matching process brings together three things: what we know about our caregivers, what we’ve learned about your mom, and the judgment of the three people who know both.

We get to know our caregivers first

Our administrator leads hiring. She talks with every applicant by phone, then brings them in to meet. Before anyone joins us, our administrator, our scheduler, and a registered nurse all weigh in on whether that person is a good fit. Every applicant also goes through a skills checklist and a skills assessment with a nurse.

Once someone is hired, we keep a record of their skills, gender, personality, schedule, and where they live. That record is what our matching software works from later.

For dementia care, we dig deeper. We ask applicants how many clients with dementia they’ve cared for and how they handle conflict and stress. Then we give them real situations and ask what they’d do first:

  • A client is angry and tells you to get out of his house.
  • You walk in, and the client is agitated.

Some applicants nail them. Some don’t, and those caregivers don’t work with our dementia clients. The truth is, not everybody is suited to work with a dementia client. We also sent our caregivers to a dementia training with educator Teepa Snow.

What does a good answer look like? We had a client who would get angry and order caregivers out of his house. What worked was saying, “Okay, I’m leaving,” going out the front door, and coming back in through the back a few minutes later with a friendly hello. By then, he’d forgotten why he was upset. If your dad is the one who needs care, that’s the kind of patience his caregiver has already shown us. And if it’s your mom, she gets the same protection: whoever walks through her door knows how to stay calm when a visit gets difficult.

Then we get to know your mom

During the consultation and assessment, we’ll ask you something simple: if you could describe your mom’s ideal caregiver, who would it be? Then we go through the details that make a match last.

  • Personality. Some people want someone quiet and serious. Others want someone a little silly. Neither is better. The right fit is whoever your mom will enjoy spending her day with.
  • Her home. Does she have a cat or a dog? Some caregivers aren’t comfortable with pets, and some have allergies. Does she have COPD (Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease) or trouble with smells? Then we think about smoking and strong perfume. Do shoes come off at the door? We want to know that too.
  • Her language. Many people with dementia go back to their first language as the disease progresses. When one of our clients went back to speaking Spanish, we matched her with caregivers who speak Spanish fluently. When another client went back to French, we matched her with caregivers who could communicate with her.
  • The help she needs. If your mom is bed-bound or needs full help bathing, she needs a skilled caregiver. We won’t send someone without that training or someone with back problems to do that job.

We’ll also ask whether she’d prefer a man or a woman, and someone older or younger, and we take that into account.

There’s good research behind the language piece. In a UCLA study of 253 people with Alzheimer’s disease, most of the bilingual patients went back to speaking only their native language as their dementia progressed. And a 2023 study in Medical Care of more than 22,000 non-English-speaking home health patients in New York City found that patients did best at staying out of the hospital when they saw the same nurse consistently, and that nurse spoke their language. Language alone wasn’t enough. That’s why we match on language and then work hard to keep the same caregiver in place.

Personality has research behind it too. A 2020 study of home care clients in the Netherlands, published in the Journal of Advanced Nursing, found that clients valued open communication, humor, and care routines that fit the way they’d always lived.

Software makes the short list, and we make the choice

Our medical record system has a matching tool built in. When we hire a caregiver, our administrator and scheduler enter their skills, traits, availability, and home zip code. When your mom becomes a client, we enter her needs and preferences. The tool then shows us the caregivers who fit and filters out the ones who don’t.

I won’t pretend our software is special. Many agencies probably use the same software. The difference is that we put it to use. A program can’t tell us that your mom lights up around someone with a sense of humor, or that a certain caregiver stays calm when things get tense. People can. Our scheduler leads the pairing, working with our administrator and a registered nurse. She used to be a caregiver, so she knows what each job really asks of the caregiver who takes it.

Why a nurse is part of every match

In Florida, matching on skill is part of a nurse’s legal responsibility. Under Florida Administrative Code rule 59A-8.0095, the registered nurse keeps full responsibility for the personal care tasks given to home health aides and has to make sure each aide is qualified for them based on training and experience. That’s one reason a nurse has a say in every match we make.

How long does matching take?

If your mom needs help right away, care can start the same day the paperwork is signed. The trade-off is that she may see a few different fill-in caregivers at first, because the person who fits her best may already be booked that day. Once her regular caregiver’s schedule opens up, the fill-ins stop. If you can give us more notice, we can have her regular caregiver lined up before the very first visit.

Want to talk through what a match might look like for your mom? Schedule a consultation, and we’ll walk you through it.

Step 4: What happens when care launches?

You approve the schedule, you and your mom can meet the caregiver before care begins, and we set up a client binder in her home.

The binder lives at your mom’s house. It holds her medication list, care plan, schedule, caregiver notes, and incident reports. If she ever has to go to the hospital, the binder goes with her, so the hospital staff can see her medications and care plan right away.

When you’re in town, we can also give you access to our medical record system, where you can see which caregiver was there each day and read their notes. If you’d rather not log in, it’s all in the binder too.

What if your mom doesn’t want help at all? Start small. Care can begin with as little as four hours, once a week, with the same caregiver. As your mom gets comfortable, we add time with the person she already knows. That’s often how “I don’t need anyone” turns into a visit she looks forward to.

Step 5: How do we know the match is working?

We check in. We don’t wait for you to call us with a problem.

Once care starts, you’ll hear from us, whether that’s a registered nurse, our administrator, or our scheduler. Here’s why: I don’t believe in placing a caregiver and assuming no news is good news. We follow up to make sure it’s a good fit, because a lot of times people don’t want to complain.

That’s true for a lot of families. Your mom may be too polite to say a personality isn’t clicking. You may not want to hurt anyone’s feelings. Our call gives everyone permission to be honest.

After that, we keep checking on a regular schedule:

  • Every 60 days, we supervise each caregiver’s work with a call or a visit.
  • Every 60 to 90 days, depending on your mom’s needs, a registered nurse reassesses her and updates her care plan.
  • If something feels off, a nurse can schedule a visit when the caregiver isn’t there, so your mom can talk freely.

Florida requires every licensed home health agency to have a registered nurse make supervisory visits to its caregivers, under that same state rule.

Every care plan also tells the caregiver to report any fall or change in your mom’s condition, no matter how small, day or night. Our on-call number is right there in the plan, and a nurse is always available.

Why do we do so much checking? A 2023 study in the Journal of Applied Gerontology found that the bond between home care aides and their clients depends on communication style, support from family and the agency, enough time to give care, and clear boundaries around tasks. A good match needs support after day one to stay good.

Step 6: What happens when needs change or care ends?

When your mom needs more, we adjust. When it’s time to stop, we step back with respect. We call this part our Compassionate Continuity Path.

Families often ask us whether a caregiver can keep up as their mom’s needs change. I hear it often: families want to know that the caregiver they start with can evolve with them. That means a caregiver who can take on more as your mom declines, like help with showers, incontinence care, or growing confusion. When she needs more help, a registered nurse reassesses her and updates the plan, ideally with the caregiver she already trusts.

If you decide to end services, for any reason, we ask for 24 hours’ notice out of respect for the caregiver. That’s it. No penalty and no long notice period. And if another agency would be a better fit for your mom, we’ll refer you to one.

At the end of life, we work alongside your mom’s hospice team. When we see the signs that the end is near, we let the family know it’s time to come, and we help set up a video call for anyone who can’t get there in person. We won’t pull a caregiver away from a grieving spouse who has counted on them every day. If that spouse needs help with meals, bathing, or just having someone there, we can stay and step back slowly. We go to the funerals, and we stay in touch with the family afterward.

How often does the first match work?

Dementia patient and caregiver smiling as they drink tea together on couch

The three of us who make our matches estimate that we get the first one right about 99% of the time.

That’s our own estimate, based on the families that we’ve served, and I’m the first to say no process is perfect. We try to get it right the first time, but being perfect all the time isn’t realistic. When the first match works, it’s because of Steps 1 through 3: meeting you in person, the nurse’s assessment, knowing our caregivers well, and three people making the final choice. When it misses, Step 5 is how we catch it early.

What happens if the match isn’t right?

We find your mom a new caregiver at no cost, under our Right Fit Guarantee.

You can call us any time, or tell us when we call you. Most of the time, we notice first because of those follow-up calls. We’ll ask what isn’t working, and we’ll use your answer to choose the next caregiver. It works best as a team effort, which means families need to be open to our suggestions too.

With more than 70 people on our staff, there’s usually another good option close by. In my experience, families are always happy the second time, at least.

If you’re on the fence about getting started, remember that you’re never locked in. Talk with us, try a match, and decide from there.

Frequently asked questions

Can my mom ask for a female or male caregiver?

Yes. We ask about it during the consultation, along with age, personality, and anything about her home we should know. We’ll match within her preferences whenever we can.

What if my mom speaks a language other than English?

Tell us at the consultation. We’ve matched clients with caregivers who speak Spanish fluently, and with caregivers who could talk with a client who went back to French. Language matters even more with dementia, because many people return to their first language as the disease progresses.

Can I be part of the process if I live out of state?

Absolutely. You can join the consultation by phone or video, approve the schedule, and get copies of every signed document by email. When you visit, we can give you access to our records so you can see who’s been there and read the caregiver notes, and the binder at your mom’s house has everything in one place.

How quickly can care start?

Often the same day the paperwork is signed, if your mom needs help right away. With a little more notice, we can have her regular caregiver ready for the very first visit. If care starts sooner, she may see a few fill-in caregivers until her regular caregiver’s schedule opens up. And if you’re still deciding how many hours she needs, it helps to look at what in-home dementia care costs at different schedules before we meet.

How can you prepare for your consultation?

Think through a few questions before we meet, and we can go further in our first conversation. These are the questions we’ll ask you:

  • If you could describe your mom’s ideal caregiver, who would it be?
  • Does she have pets, allergies, or trouble with smoke or strong scents?
  • What language is she most comfortable speaking?
  • Is there anything about her home a caregiver should know, like taking shoes off at the door?
  • What help does she need today, and what does she still want to do herself?

Jot down your answers. And if you’re comparing agencies, bring any questions from our guide on questions to ask a home care agency.

Getting started with the MatchCare Method

Now that you know how we do it, step by step. Your next step is to have a conversation about your mom: who she is, what she needs, and what kind of person would make her days easier.

We serve families in Naples, Fort Myers, Cape Coral, and throughout Collier and Lee Counties. We’ll meet you wherever it’s convenient, or by phone if you’re out of state, and we’ll answer every question you bring. No pressure and no commitment. Schedule a consultation, and let’s start with the question we ask every family: Who is your mom’s ideal caregiver?

Recent Posts

Caregiver smiling as she sits with her dementia patient while talking on the couch over coffee in her patient's home

Why Southwest Florida Families Choose Our Dementia Home Care Agency

Families choose our dementia home care agency for five commitments: matched caregivers, a familiar team, nurse oversight, covered ...
Happy dementia patient enjoying a conversation while having breakfast with her caregiver at her table in her home

Reliable Home Care Means That You’re Never Without Care

Our Never Without Care promise means every scheduled visit happens with a qualified person. If your mom's regular ...
Dementia patient and caregiver smiling at each other as they stand in front of a window together in the patient's home

Why Private-Pay Dementia Care Is Different

With private-pay dementia care, your family decides how many hours of care your mom gets. You decide which ...